IsMyGuy vs. OnlyFans: Which Platform for Men?

If you’re a male content creator and are looking for a way to diversify and increase your income, you may have looked into premium fan clubs or social media platforms. One of the most prominent is OnlyFans which is a household name at this point. But what about a platform strictly for men? Allow us to introduce you to IsMyGuy, the all-male platform from the creator of IsMyGirl

IsMyGuy is an all-male platform from the creator of IsMyGirl that has many of the same features as its sister site. With strategic partnerships of over 35 million followers strong, they have a massive network they can help promote you on.

OnlyFans is one of the most popular fan clubs or premium social media platforms in the world. Content creators are able to monetize their photos, videos, audio files, and anything else they want to create for their biggest fans. It quickly became a household name in the early parts of 2020.

In this article, we’ll compare and contrast the two platforms so you can get a clear idea of which one would work for you. By the end of the article, you will know exactly which premium social media platform will help you grow a fan base, gain dedicated subscribers, and make a lot of money.

Ways models make money on IsMyGuy and OnlyFans

One of the most important things to consider when choosing a platform to create content on is what you’re able to sell. We’ll compare and contrast he opportunities on IsMyGuy and OnlyFans now.

You can create content and make money on IsMyGuy by

  • Monthly subscription services between $10 and $60
  • Pay to unlock clip store starting at $10
  • Pay to unlock private messages
  • Custom content
  • Premium Snapchat management
  • Live streaming
  • 1-on-1 camming
  • Tipping
  • The referral program

how to make money on ismyguy

There are a few ways to make money on OnlyFans, including

💰 Monthly subscription services between $4.99 and $50
💌 Pay per message with a $3 minimum and $100 maximum
🦄 Creating custom content for fans
🥴 Tips from fans with a minimum of $3 and a max of $200
🔃 Referral program (there’s a whole section below with more detail)

how to make money on onlyfans

IsMyGuy has really created a one-stop-shop for all your content creation and selling needs. From the basics like monthly subscriptions and tips to being able to live stream and premium Snap management, IsMyGuy works best if you’re not already doing something like streaming on another platform.

If you are a cam model or similar, depending on your site they may see IsMyGuy as competition because there are live-streaming capabilities built-in. Keep that in mind if that is the case.

Payout rates & frequency for IsMyGuy and OnlyFans

Another important aspect of choosing a platform is how much and how often you get paid out.

IsMyGuy pays out 80% on all subscriptions, video sales, and tips and pays out 70% on all live streaming. The 20 and 30 percent, respectively, go toward payment processing, hosting, maintenance, and research & development.

ismyguy payout percentage

The pay periods for IsMyGuy are the 1st to the 15th and the 16th through to the end of the month. There is a $50 minimum for withdrawals and they are automatically deposited by the 2nd & 17th of the month, assuming you meet the minimum requirements. If not, those earnings are carried over to the next month until you break that threshold.

when to get pain ismyguy

OnlyFans pays out 80% to its creators with the other 20% going to website maintenance, payment processing, referral payments, hosting, support, and other website needs.

onlyfans payout percentage

Most users have a $20 minimum to withdraw their earnings. Content creators can make withdrawals manually every day or have automatic withdrawals weekly every Monday or on the 1st of the month. 

There is a 7-day period from the time you earn your money to the time you’re able to make a withdrawal. This is to cover any chargebacks or other fraudulent payments. For some models, this is a 21-day period but switches to a 7-day period four months after 1st withdrawal.

onlyfans money payout frequency

Luckily both IsMyGuy and OnlyFans pay the industry standard 80%. If you’re interested in more frequent withdrawals OnlyFans is your best bet, assuming you make their minimums. If you like payments more on par with a 9 to 5, IsMyGuy’s bimonthly payouts are where it’s at.

Which platform helps models get more fans

For both established influencers and brand new models, how much a platform helps you grow can increase your revenue substantially week over week. We’ll take a deeper look at whether IsMyGuy or OnlyFans helps their guys get more subscribers and make more money.

IsMyGuy boasts a massive network on social media that helps new fans find you. The onsite search allows users to browse the newest verified men. Although it is not a requirement, if you are exclusive to the platform they will promote you heavily on their social network and even feature you on the homepage of the platform.

ismyguy promotion help

One of the biggest complaints about OnlyFans is that there is no way for accounts to be browsed. If you’re not driving traffic to your page, you’re not being discovered. This can be a major blow to brand new models that may not already have a large social media following.

But we do have good news for you! You may opt to use our own promotion service where you can promote your page on. Just visit to get started!

It’s a no-brainer here, IsMyGuy gives a damn about you and wants to see you succeed. If you’re an established content creator you could use the skills you have to succeed on OnlyFans, but for a brand new model, we recommend IsMyGuy.

Which referral program is better

For those not in the know, a platform’s referral program is an incentive for you to find new models to create content.

IsMyGuy’s referral program offers you 5% of all earnings for every model you refer forever. You can refer to an unlimited amount of models.

ismyguy referral program

The OnlyFans referral program pays out 5% earnings for every model you refer to the site for the first 12 months they’re on OnlyFans. There is a $50,000 earning limit you can make for every model you refer to OnlyFans. So if a model makes more than $1,000,000 in its first year, you’re capped at $50,000 for that model. There is no limit to the number of models you can refer to OnlyFans.

OnlyFans Referral Program

Which should you use IsMyGuy or OnlyFans

If you’re an established content creator you could get away with using OnlyFans. However, we truly believe that a site like IsMyGuy is worth your time and energy, especially with all the controversies surrounding OnlyFans the last few years.

To learn more about IsMyGuy and read a full overview and review of the platform, click here. If you’re interested in joining IsMyGuy, click here to sign up and start earning money today.

More information about IsMyGuy:

To learn more about OnlyFans and read a full overview and review of the platform, click here. If you’re interested in joining OnlyFans, click here to sign up and start earning money today.

More information about OnlyFans:

Gentlemen, we have a series of articles on how you can start earning money with sex work, both online and offline. Our recommended webcam websites to start earning is Chaturbate or Stripchat, and if you’re trying to earn money by chatting with people and earning subscribers, LoyalFans is your best bet.

To explore other ways of making money as a male sexually, check out these articles:

Are you a content creator? Take our 2023 earnings survey here! Only 13 questions long!
Get a 75% off coupon to for participating!
💰 Five randomly selected participants will receive $100! 💰
(Note: the survey is in English)